Company Members

1st Auto & Casualty Insurance Company

1st Auto & Casualty Insurance Company

  • Contact: Ms. Cathleen R. McAnaugh
  • Telephone: (608) 242-4505
  • Description

    Property & Casualty Insurance Company that partners with small mutuals to provide insurance products.
    AAA Wisconsin

    AAA Wisconsin

  • Contact: Mr. Leo Plese
  • Telephone: (608) 236-1300
  • Description

    AAA Wisconsin, which serves more than 600,000 members, offers automotive, travel, insurance and financial services.
    Acuity

    Acuity

  • Contact: Mr. David J. Wulff
  • Telephone: (800) 242-7666
  • Acuity

    Acuity

  • Contact: Mr. John C. Kautzer
  • Telephone: (920) 458-9131
  • Auto-Owners Insurance Company

    Auto-Owners Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Scott Coykendall
  • Telephone: (920) 993-8550
  • Description

    Property/Casualty and Life Insurance Company with multiple affiliate companies that offer products in many areas including personal, commercial, farm, bonds, life annuities, disability income and long term care. Also, excess and surplus lines.
    Badger Mutual Insurance

    Badger Mutual Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Melissa Theisen
  • Telephone: (414) 383-1234
  • Description

    Wisconsin based insurance carrier that has been headquartered in Milwaukee since 1187, providing a range of personal and commercial insurance products.
    Continental Western Group-A Berkley Co

    Continental Western Group-A Berkley Co

  • Contact: Mr. Joel Jellings
  • Telephone: (515) 473-3058
  • Description

    Commercial Middle Market Products AG, Manufacturing, Food Processing, Construction

    Ellington Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Howard Schwartz
  • Telephone: (920) 779-4515
  • Description

    A Wisconsin based property and casualty carrier providing both personal lines and from all commercial programs
    EMC Insurance Companies

    EMC Insurance Companies

  • Contact: Ms. Haley Clark
  • Telephone: (262) 717-3926
  • Description

    Property & Casualty Insurance
    Erie Indemnity Group

    Erie Indemnity Group

  • Contact: Ms. Rita Napieralski
  • Telephone: (262) 717-6300
  • Description

    Since 1925 Erie Insurance has grown to become the 16th largest auto insurance and 18th largest property/casualty insurer in the United States. As a regional insurance company operating in eleven states, we finished 2009 with nearly $4 billion in written premium volume. We currently have 126 agencies located throughout Wisconsin with nearly $75 million in profitable business. Erie has penetrated the Wisconsin Top 20 in market share for the Personal Auto and Homeowners lines as of end 2009. Erie commenced Wisconsin operations September 1, 2001.

    Farmington Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Tony Wilke
  • Telephone: (715) 748-6040
  • Description

    Specialty Farm and Monoline Homeowners
    Frankenmuth Insurance

    Frankenmuth Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Sara Wallace
  • Telephone: (989) 652-6121
  • Description

    Frankenmuth Insurance has been in business 150 years. We work exclusively with independent agents to provide business, home, auto and life insurance. In Wisconsin, we write commercial lines business, property and casualty, workers compensation and commercial coverages.

    Fremont Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Rich Fasi
  • Telephone: (231) 924-8411
  • Description

    Founded in 1876 as a Farm Mutual, we write personal, commercial and farm policies.
    Germantown Mutual Insurance Company

    Germantown Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Richard R. Smith
  • Telephone: (262) 402-4633
  • Description

    P & C
    Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

    Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

  • Contact: Ms. Monica Tews
  • Telephone: (641) 269-8233
  • Description

    Property & Casualty
    Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

    Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Tom G. Becker
  • Telephone: (800) 442-8277
  • Description

    Property & Casualty generalist

    ICW Group Insurance Companies

  • Contact: Ms. Christina McGuire
  • Telephone: (217) 391-8405
  • Description

    Work compensation
    IMT Insurance

    IMT Insurance

  • Contact: Mr. Troy Neil
  • Telephone: (515) 453-0730
  • Description

    IMT Insurance is a Regional Insurance carrier that offers a strong line of personal and commercial insurance products.
    Integrity Insurance

    Integrity Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Cathy Colon
  • Telephone: (920) 968-8326
  • Description

    With a long history of supporting indpendent agents and a customizable lineup of business, home, auto & life insurance, Integrity offers the stability of a large insurance carrier and the personalized service of a small business.
    KEMPER

    KEMPER

  • Contact: Mr. Austin R. Durham
  • Telephone: (262) 207-8820
  • Description

    Kemper proudly works with independent agents who provide customers with a choice of insurance programs to fit their individual needs.

    Little Black Mutual Ins. Co.

  • Telephone: (715) 748-6040
  • Description

    Homeowners, Farmowners & small business
    Maple Valley Mutual Insurance Co.

    Maple Valley Mutual Insurance Co.

  • Contact: Mr. Chad Schuettpelz
  • Telephone: (920) 829-5525
  • McMillan Warner Mutual Insurance Co.

  • Contact: Mr. Scott Krum
  • Telephone: (715) 387-8454
  • Description

    Farm, Home & Rentals

    Merrimac Lodi Mutual Ins. Company

  • Contact: Ms. Vicki B. Kearney
  • Telephone: (608) 644-1900
  • Description

    Property and Casualty Town Mutual Insurance Company
    MetLife Auto & Home

    MetLife Auto & Home

  • Contact: Mr. James Gulbransen
  • Telephone: (952) 948-5071
  • Motorists Insurance Group

    Motorists Insurance Group

  • Contact: Ms. Megan Wetli
  • Telephone: (614) 225-8389
  • Description

    Motorists Insurance Group and BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Co. affiliated through a joint venture in 2017. Ohio-based Motorists consists of property and casualty insurance, life insurance and insurance brokerage companies, and West Virginia-based BrickStreet is one of the largest writers of workers' compensation coverage in the region.Now a super-regional carrier ranked in the top 20 mutual companies in the United States, Motorists and BrickStreet include more than 1,600 associates, 10 offices writing in 29 states, premiums of nearly $1.2 billion, a surplus of nearly $1.55 billion and assets of $4.5 billion. The group markets insurance solutions through more than 17,000 independent agents at more than 2,000 agencies in the Midwest, Northeast and South. Learn more about Motorists Insurance Group at motoristsinsurancegroup.com and BrickStreet at brickstreet.com.
    Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company

    Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Daniel Fenske
  • Telephone: (877) 228-5541
  • Description

    Mt. Morris Mutual proudly partners with over 125 independent agencies throughout the state. SERVICE to agents and insureds remain top priority. The Company provides a comprehensive farm package that can be specifically designed to cover all types of agricultural operations. Home, Commercial, Umbrella, Personal and Commercial Auto make Mt. Morris your one stop shop for all property/casualty insurance.

    Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual Ins. Co.

  • Contact: Mr. Bob Goehring
  • Telephone: (608) 938-4008
  • Description

    Town Mutual offering Farm, Home & Commercial P&C insurance in southern Wisconsin.
    Nationwide Insurance

    Nationwide Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Alice Terrell
  • Telephone: (515) 508-5480
  • Description

    We are fortune 91 company offering all lines of business including personal lines, commercial lines, farm and financial products.
    Partners Mutual Insurance Company

    Partners Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Richard Keith
  • Telephone: (262) 798-5050
  • Description

    We sell a diverse array of business, auto and home insurance. We only sell through indpendent insruance agents.

    Pennsylvania Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Christopher Crucitt
  • Telephone: (800) 752-1895
  • Description

    Property and Casualty insurance dedicated to lumber, woodworking and building material ndustries.
    Progressive Insurance

    Progressive Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Corinne DeJohn
  • Telephone: (440) 395-7228
  • Description

    Auto, Boat, Motorcycle, RV
    Rockford Mutual Insurance Company

    Rockford Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Shane Heeren
  • Telephone: (815) 489-3214
  • Description

    Property and Casualty Insurance Company - personal lines, commercial lines and farm.
    SECURA Insurance

    SECURA Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Sherri Fassbender
  • Telephone: (800) 558-3405
  • SECURA Insurance

    SECURA Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Barbara A. Rufenacht
  • Telephone: (608) 824-3495
  • Selective Insurance Company of America

    Selective Insurance Company of America

  • Contact: Mr. Erik Reidenbach
  • Telephone: (317) 815-4343
  • Description

    Selective is a super-regional insurance company that offers standard and E&S coverage through independent agents, with the customer service capabilities, product offering and technical know-how of a national carrier.
    Society Insurance

    Society Insurance

  • Contact: Ms. Linda Kath
  • Telephone: (920) 922-1220
  • Description

    Property and Casualty Insurance
    State Auto Insurance Companies

    State Auto Insurance Companies

  • Contact: Ms. Laura Taylor
  • Telephone: (608) 779-8653
  • The Cincinnati Insurance Companies

  • Contact: Mr. Bill Clevidence
  • Telephone: (513) 870-2953
  • Description

    Property, Casualty & Life Insurance Company
    The Hanover Insurance Group

    The Hanover Insurance Group

  • Contact: Mr. Brent Timmerman
  • Telephone: (630) 521-8430
  • Description

    A compelling partner for challenging times. A national company with a regional approach.
    The Hanover Insurance Group

    The Hanover Insurance Group

  • Contact: Mr. Matt Kanitz
  • Telephone: (262) 796-6728
  • Description

    Property Casualty - Auto & Home Insurance, Inland Marine, Surety, Commercial Lines, Speicalty Lines - Mgmt Liability, A&E, Professional Liability, Technology

    The Hartford Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Joshua C. Timm
  • Telephone: (312) 384-7591
  • Description

    With more than 200 years of experience, The Hartford is a leader in property and casualty insurance, group benefits and mutual funds.
    United Fire Group

    United Fire Group

  • Contact: Mr. Patrick Kane
  • Telephone: (319) 286-2456
  • West Bend - A Mutual Insurance Company

    West Bend - A Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Ms. Sarah Riehle
  • Telephone: (262) 338-5010
  • Description

    West Bend provides Commercial, Personal, Argent, NSI & Bonds
    West Bend Mutual/Argent

    West Bend Mutual/Argent

  • Contact: Mr. Paul Hingtgen
  • Telephone: (888) 236-5008
  • Description

    West Bend provides property/casualty insurance products throughout the Midwest. The company offers a broad personal lines package, a full range of commercial lines products and services including specialty lines.
    West Bend Mutual/NSI

    West Bend Mutual/NSI

  • Contact: Ms. Anna Maas
  • Telephone: (800) 760-9250
  • Description

    West Bend provides property/casualty insurance products throughout the Midwest. The company offers a broad personal lines package, a full range of commercial lines products and services including specialty lines.
    Western National Insurance Group

    Western National Insurance Group

  • Contact: Mr. Scott Bauer
  • Telephone: (952) 921-5601
  • Description

    Regional P & C A+ rated
    Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company

    Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Mr. Dan A. Keyes
  • Telephone: (608) 836-4663
  • Description

    P&C Insurer
    Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company

    Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company

  • Contact: Ms. Holly Laufenberg
  • Telephone: (608) 452-3275
  • Featured Benefit: Bottled Water

    water bottlesClick Here for more information about water bottles

    PIA Large

    Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin
    6401 Odana Road | Madison, WI 53719
    Phone: (608) 274-8188 | Toll Free (800) 261-7429
    Fax: (608) 274-8195 | Toll Free (866) 203-7461

    pia-national-news